Silicone vs Plastic Ice Cube Trays: Which Is Better?
Share
Quick answer: Silicone ice cube trays release cubes more easily and come in large shapes like 2 inch cubes and spheres. Plastic trays are rigid, so they are easier to carry full of water and stack in the freezer. For large cocktail cubes, choose silicone. For everyday small cubes in bulk, a plastic tray with a lid and bin works well.
An ice cube tray seems like the simplest thing in the kitchen until you are twisting a frozen tray over the sink and half the cubes crack while the other half refuse to come out. Or you fill a floppy tray to the brim and spill water across the freezer shelf on the way in. The material makes most of the difference. Silicone and plastic each solve some of these problems and create others. Here is how they compare on release, shape, handling, taste, and cleaning, so you can pick the right tray for how you actually use ice.
Which releases ice more easily, silicone or plastic?
Silicone releases ice more easily because it bends, so you can push each cube out from the bottom one at a time. Plastic trays need a twist across the whole tray, which pops cubes loose all at once and often cracks a few.
The flexibility of silicone is its main advantage. Large cubes of 1.5 to 2 inches would be very hard to free from a rigid tray, but silicone lets you peel the mold away from the ice. That is why nearly all big cocktail cubes and sphere molds are made of silicone.
Plastic trays work best with small cubes, roughly 1 to 1.25 inches, where a quick twist cracks the ice free. Many plastic trays now have flexible bottoms or a thin silicone base to make release easier, which gives you some of the benefit of both.
Which is easier to fill and carry to the freezer?
Plastic is easier to fill and carry because it stays rigid, so a full tray will not bend and spill on the way to the freezer. A soft silicone tray can sag in the middle when full, especially larger trays holding 15 or more cubes.
A few ways to handle silicone trays without spills:
- Set the empty tray on a flat freezer shelf first, then fill it with a pitcher.
- Choose silicone trays with a stiff plastic frame or a metal ring around the edge.
- Pick trays with a fitted lid, which also keeps cubes from absorbing freezer odors.
Plastic trays with a lid and a storage bin underneath are especially convenient. You freeze a batch, twist the cubes into the bin, and refill the tray right away.
Do silicone or plastic trays make better shapes?
Silicone makes better large and decorative shapes, such as 2 inch cubes, 1.8 to 2.5 inch spheres, and long sticks that fit into tumblers and bottles. Plastic is best for standard small cubes and nugget-style ice.
Large cubes and spheres melt more slowly because they have less surface area for their volume. That keeps a drink cold with less dilution, which is why they are popular for whiskey, iced coffee, and cocktails. Silicone also handles fun shapes, such as hearts, letters, or sports balls, that would be impossible to remove from a rigid mold.
For everyday drinks, lemonade, or a full pitcher of iced tea, small plastic-tray cubes are perfectly good and chill a glass faster because there is more ice surface touching the liquid.
Do silicone trays make ice taste different?
New silicone trays can give ice a faint rubbery or soapy taste at first, but this usually goes away after a few washes. Food-grade silicone does not leach flavor once it has been cleaned and aired out.
To clear the taste from a new silicone tray:
- Wash it in hot, soapy water and rinse well.
- Soak it for 30 minutes in a mix of warm water and a spoonful of baking soda.
- Run it through the top rack of the dishwasher once or twice.
- Make one or two batches of ice and throw them away.
Both silicone and plastic trays can pick up freezer smells from foods like onions or fish. A lid, or storing finished ice in a sealed bin, keeps cubes tasting clean.
Is silicone or plastic safer for ice?
Both are safe for ice when they are labeled food-grade, and with plastic you should look for trays marked BPA-free. Ice trays only touch cold water, so there is very little risk of chemicals moving into the ice either way.
Food-grade silicone is stable across a wide range, roughly minus 40 to over 400 degrees Fahrenheit, so it also works for baking small treats, freezing baby food, or making chocolate. Most plastic trays are made from polypropylene, which is also food-safe but can crack after years of twisting in the freezer.
If you freeze purees or broth in portions, silicone is easier because the frozen blocks pop out cleanly. You can then store them in a labeled bag or container.
Which lasts longer and is easier to clean?
Silicone lasts longer because it does not crack when twisted or dropped, while plastic trays tend to develop cracks after a year or two of regular use. Both are dishwasher safe on the top rack.
Silicone does have a few cleaning quirks:
- It can hold onto oils, so wash it by itself rather than with greasy pans.
- White film from hard water can appear. A short soak in vinegar removes it.
- Its slightly grippy surface collects lint, so dry it with a lint-free cloth or let it air dry.
Plastic is simple to wipe clean but can stain from coffee or juice if you freeze those often. Store either type flat to keep the shape true.
How many ice cube trays do you need?
Most households need two to three standard trays of 14 to 16 cubes each, or one tray set with a storage bin, to keep ice on hand every day. A single tray rarely keeps up, because it takes 3 to 4 hours to refreeze after you empty it.
A rough guide by use:
- One or two people, occasional drinks: two standard trays.
- Family of four: three to four trays, or a two-tray set that empties into a bin.
- Cocktails or iced coffee every day: one large-cube silicone mold of 4 to 6 cubes, plus a standard tray for everything else.
- Parties: make ice a day or two ahead and store it in a lidded bin or freezer bag so the trays are free to refill.
Stackable trays save the most freezer space. Look for flat lids that let a second tray sit on top without tilting, and keep the stack on a level shelf so water does not spill before it freezes.
Which one should you buy?
Buy silicone if you want large cubes, spheres, or ice for cocktails and iced coffee. Buy plastic, ideally with a lid and bin, if you want a steady supply of small cubes for the whole household.
Many kitchens keep one of each. A plastic tray set covers daily ice, and a silicone mold makes slow-melting cubes for drinks and guests. A few extras make ice easier to use:
- A scoop and storage bin so you are not digging through the freezer by hand.
- Glassware and bar tools from our corkscrews and bar range for serving.
- A citrus juicer for fresh lemonade and cocktails over your new ice.
If you also use molds for treats, browse baking tools and measuring and mixing sets that pair well with silicone trays.
Frequently asked questions
Are silicone ice cube trays better than plastic?
Silicone is better for large cubes and easy release, while plastic is better for carrying full trays and making small cubes in bulk. The best choice depends on the ice you use most.
Why does my ice taste like silicone?
New silicone can leave a faint taste. Wash it in hot soapy water, soak it in baking soda solution, run it through the dishwasher, and discard the first one or two batches of ice.
How long does it take to freeze large ice cubes?
Standard small cubes freeze in about 3 to 4 hours. Large 2 inch cubes and spheres take 6 to 8 hours, so overnight is the safe choice.
Can you put silicone ice trays in the dishwasher?
Yes. Most silicone and plastic ice trays are top-rack dishwasher safe. Wash silicone separately from greasy dishes so it does not absorb oil.