Stainless steel rimmed sheet pan next to a matching wire cooling rack on a white background

Cookie Sheet vs Baking Sheet: Which Pan for What

Quick answer: A cookie sheet is flat with one or two raised edges, so air moves over cookies and they slide off easily. A baking sheet has a rim about 1 inch high on all four sides, so juices stay on the pan. Use a cookie sheet for cookies, and a rimmed 18 by 13 inch sheet for nearly everything else.

Shop Baking Tools →

Most recipes say "baking sheet" and most kitchens hold one or two pans that get used for everything. That works until the roasted vegetables drip onto the oven floor or a batch of cookies browns on the edges and stays pale in the middle. The two pans look alike but they do different jobs, and the difference comes down to a small strip of metal along the edge. This guide explains what each pan is, which sizes fit a home oven, which materials brown best, and which one to reach for first.

What is the difference between a cookie sheet and a baking sheet?

A cookie sheet has no rim on at least two sides, while a baking sheet has a rim about 1 inch tall on all four sides. The open edges of a cookie sheet let hot air reach the cookies from every direction and let a spatula slide straight under them.

Here is the short version:

  • Cookie sheet: flat, with one or two raised lips to grip. Best for cookies, biscuits, and scones.
  • Baking sheet: rimmed on all sides. Also called a sheet pan or rimmed baking sheet.
  • Jelly roll pan: a smaller rimmed pan, close to 15 by 10 inches, made for thin sponge cakes.

The words get mixed up all the time, even in cookbooks and on packaging. When a recipe says "baking sheet" and does not mention a rim, either pan will usually do. When it involves anything liquid, oily, or juicy, use the rim. Our baking collection has the liners and racks that work with both kinds.

Which pan is better for baking cookies?

A cookie sheet is better for cookies because the low edges let heat move evenly across the pan, so the outer cookies do not brown faster than the center ones. A rimmed sheet still works, but cookies near the rim can bake a little more slowly.

Results depend on more than the shape. Three details matter most:

  • Color: light metal gives soft, even browning. Dark pans run hotter, so drop the oven by 25°F or check the batch 2 minutes early.
  • Spacing: leave about 2 inches between cookies so they can spread.
  • Liner: a silicone mat or parchment stops sticking and slows the browning on the bottom a little.

If you only own a rimmed sheet, turn it upside down and bake on the flat back. That gives you the same open edge as a cookie sheet. Move finished cookies to a wire rack after 2 to 3 minutes. Leaving them on a hot pan keeps them cooking from below. Timing makes a real difference with cookies, so a simple kitchen timer helps when you bake back-to-back trays.

What is a baking sheet best used for?

A baking sheet is best for anything that releases liquid or could roll off the pan, including roasted vegetables, chicken, bacon, fish, and sheet pan dinners. The 1 inch rim holds in juices and oil, and it makes the pan safer to carry out of a hot oven.

This is the pan to use for:

  • Roasting vegetables and potatoes.
  • Sheet pan dinners with meat and sides.
  • Oven bacon, which releases a lot of fat.
  • Sheet cakes and thin bar cookies.
  • Holding pie plates and casseroles that may bubble over.

For the best roast, keep food in a single layer with a little space between pieces. Crowded food steams instead of browning. If you are cooking for four or more, use two pans rather than one full pan. Set a wire rack inside the rim for bacon, breaded chicken, or anything you want crisp on all sides. The rack lifts food above its drippings and lets air pass underneath.

What size baking sheet do you need?

A half sheet pan, about 18 by 13 inches, is the most useful size for a home kitchen, as it fits a standard 30 inch oven with space around the edges for air. Quarter sheets, about 13 by 9 inches, are good for small batches and toaster ovens.

Common sizes look like this:

  • Full sheet: 26 by 18 inches. Too large for most home ovens.
  • Half sheet: 18 by 13 inches. The home standard.
  • Quarter sheet: 13 by 9 inches. Good for sides and small roasts.
  • Eighth sheet: 9 by 6.5 inches. Handy for toppings and prep.

Before buying, measure the inside of your oven and leave at least 1 inch of clearance on each side. A pan that touches the walls blocks airflow and causes uneven baking. Check your racks and liners against the pan too. A half sheet mat measures about 16.5 by 11.6 inches so that it can sit flat inside the rim, and a wire rack should rest fully inside the pan with no overhang.

Which material is best for sheet pans?

Heavy aluminum is the best all-around material for sheet pans, because it heats quickly and evenly. Aluminized steel adds strength and holds up better over time, while stainless steel resists stains and rust but heats less evenly on its own.

Here is how each performs:

  • Aluminum: light, heats evenly, and gives gentle browning. Avoid long contact with acidic food like tomatoes.
  • Aluminized steel: strong and resistant to warping.
  • Stainless steel: durable and easy to scrub, but slower to heat and more prone to hot spots.
  • Nonstick coating: easy release, but keep it under the maker's stated heat limit and use soft tools.

Thickness matters as much as material. Thin pans warp with a loud pop in a hot oven, which can throw food around. Look for a pan with a rolled edge, as the rim adds strength. To protect any surface, cook on a liner and use silicone or wood cooking utensils rather than metal. Place hot pans on a trivet or pot holder, since a cold wet counter can shock the metal and warp it.

Do you need both pans, and how do you care for them?

Most home cooks need two rimmed half sheet pans and can skip the cookie sheet unless they bake cookies every week. Two identical rimmed pans let you rotate batches, and either pan will flip over for a flat surface when you need one.

A simple starter set looks like this:

  • Two rimmed half sheet pans.
  • Two silicone baking mats sized for those pans.
  • One or two wire cooling racks that fit inside the rim.
  • One flat cookie sheet, only if you bake often.

To keep pans working well, let them cool before you wash them, and avoid running bare aluminum through the dishwasher, since detergent can dull it. Soak baked-on spots in warm soapy water, then use a soft scrub. A brown patina on older pans is normal and does not affect how they bake. Store them on edge if you can, because stacking can scratch coatings. When you mix a new batch, measuring cups and mixing bowls keep amounts consistent, and that helps every tray bake the same way.

Frequently asked questions

Can you use a baking sheet instead of a cookie sheet?

Yes. A rimmed baking sheet works fine for cookies, though the edges can slow browning a little. Flip it upside down and bake on the flat back if you want an open edge.

Is a sheet pan the same as a baking sheet?

Yes, in most recipes the two names mean the same pan: a flat metal pan with a rim about 1 inch high on all four sides. Cookie sheets are the ones without a full rim.

Why do my cookies burn on the bottom?

Dark pans, thin pans, and a rack set too low are the usual causes. Use a lighter pan or a silicone mat, bake on the middle rack, and try lowering the oven by 25°F.

Can you put a silicone baking mat on a cookie sheet?

Yes. Silicone mats work on cookie sheets and rimmed pans, as long as the mat sits flat. Choose a mat a little smaller than the pan so that it does not curl up at the edges.

Back to blog